Guest editorial: Hay is sucking the Colorado River dry

Samuel Shaw, High Country News
The All-American Canal traverses the Sonoran Desert and feeds Imperial Valley farms in California. A quarter of the 2.4 million acre-feet of water the canal brings into the valley goes to alfalfa fields.
NASA, International Space Station

When California, Arizona and Nevada agreed recently to stop using 3 million acre-feet of Colorado River water — about a trillion gallons — in order to protect their drinking supply, they took aim at one especially thirsty user: hay. So-called “forage crops” like alfalfa and Bermuda grass, which are used to feed livestock, mainly cattle, require mind-altering amounts of water to cultivate. For the next three years, the states agreed to pay farmers who ordinarily grow livestock feed $1.2 billion not to. That alone is estimated to conserve the lion’s share of the trillion-gallon target.

Alfalfa, meaning “father of all foods” in Arabic, is the nutrient-rich linchpin of the dairy and beef business. No other field crop produces more protein per acre. But that bounty comes with high water use. Alfalfa has a long growing season — another plus for farmers — a deep root system and a leafy, dense canopy that needs immense moisture to stay green. But that’s not the whole story: A century-old legal doctrine compels farmers to use as much river water as they’re allotted, or else lose access to the unused portion in the future. That perverse incentive, combined with the cheap Colorado River water afforded to many Western water districts, means that wasteful irrigation methods have not gone out of fashion. That includes a technique called “flood irrigation,” which is exactly what it sounds like: watering hundreds of alfalfa acres at a time by briefly flooding the field.

It’s a popular solution; the practice is simple to implement, recharges underground aquifers, and can create temporary havens for migrating birds. But it’s also wildly inefficient. So are those “central pivot” sprinklers that water perfect circles of crops — the ones that look like scattered green coins from an airplane window or a satellite. Those steel arms sweeping across the fields are less wasteful than flood irrigation, but far below the efficiency achieved by drip systems. Arizona and California alfalfa watered by the rolling sprinklers can soak up 800 to 1,200 gallons per minute, per sprinkler, during summer months. In contrast, a typical eight-minute shower at home uses about 17 gallons. All told, alfalfa swallows triple the water used by every household in all seven states that the river supplies.

California’s Imperial Valley, a juggernaut of hay output, laps up more water than anywhere in the whole Colorado River Basin, accounting for 80% of the state’s allotment. A quarter of the 2.4 million acre-feet the All-American Canal brings into the valley goes to alfalfa fields. Located in the Sonoran Desert, it’s one of the hottest places in California and one of the driest, too — even drier than Las Vegas, averaging three inches of rain a year. All of that poses a problem for alfalfa, which gets stressed when soil moisture drops and temperatures climb. So, in order to keep the fields healthy in hot places like the Imperial Valley, southern Arizona and central Nevada, farms make up the difference in other ways, primarily by using irrigation to simulate Michigan-levels of rain in the desert. Heat-stressed alfalfa can require the equivalent of 36 inches of precipitation in a single growing season. Since regions like the Imperial Valley receive a fraction of that, farmers turn to water sources like the Colorado River to make up the rest.

It dominates agriculture in Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and Utah, the four driest states in the country, all of which depend on the Colorado River. 

Farmers working in unforgiving desert climates have their own reasons for cultivating alfalfa. For one, with enough irrigation, it can handle the ferocious summers in the West better than many fruit and vegetable varieties. It’s also a serious cash crop: Between 2012 and 2021 in California, alfalfa fetched more dollars per ton than any other hay variety for nine years straight. It dominates agriculture in Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and Utah, the four driest states in the country, all of which depend on the Colorado River. 

In fact, much of the Colorado River is exported as hay. Rising demand for dairy products in the Middle East and skyrocketing beef consumption across the globe are driving up the demand; 40% of the alfalfa grown in California in 2020 was shrink-wrapped, containerized, and shipped to cows on the other side of Earth. 

When states and the federal government come to the table to finalize plans for the river cuts, they’ll have to balance those financial gains against the water requirements of the Southwest’s people, ecosystems and other crops. Meanwhile, the federal government still needs to review last week’s deal, and the states and the other parties involved will have to hammer out the finer points over the next several months.

Samuel Shaw is an editorial intern for High Country News based in the Colorado Front Range. This article was originally published by High Country News and is republished by permission.


More Dogs on Main: ‘George Washington peed here’

I just returned from an interesting vacation in the mysterious East. This is the annual bike trip with a very eclectic group of friends who have been doing these trips in one form or another for about 40 years now. This year we were in the Finger Lakes area of New York. It was strikingly different from here.

See more

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Park City and Summit County make the Park Record's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.