Guest editorial: Utah ranks No.1, and why that’s a bad thing |

Guest editorial: Utah ranks No.1, and why that’s a bad thing

Donna McAleer, Democratic Candidate for Congressional Dist. 1,

Utah’s landscape is among the most iconic in the country. We boast having three of the top ten ski resorts in North America. Utah was awarded the best state for business and careers by Forbes three straight years and is one of the few states maintaining a AAA rating. The Beehive State has been ranked in the top 10 for state business tax climate and a low regulatory environment. We have the youngest and healthiest workforce in America. The Pew Center named Utah "Best-managed State." Utah has two cities named in consecutive years as the best city to live in by Outdoor magazine. Utah is a picture perfect postcard image of gleaming cities, majestic mountains, and perpetually smiling residents with a growing economy. Yet for women, a group that makes up 44 percent of the state’s workforce, Utah’s stunning landscape represents a gilded cage.

A 2013 study by 24/7 Wall Street on the status of women in America ranked Utah at #1 as the worst state in the nation for women. And 24/7 Wall Street is not alone in its findings. A 2013 study of women’s economic security, career opportunities, and health by the Center for American Progress also graded Utah an "F."

On average, women’s pay in Utah is 70 percent that of their male counterparts for comparable work. In fact on the list of top ten worst cities for pay equity for women, Utah has two cities that rank #1 and #2. Utah has the worst funded schools in the nation as well as the highest student to teacher ratios. In addition, the rate of Utah women graduating from college has dropped. It is now below the national average and indications are that this slide will get worse.

It would be nice if these and other similar studies were simply collections of ivory tower arcana to be read, filed away, and then forgotten. But they’re not. They spotlight an inequity that is a drag with far-reaching consequences on our state’s economic future. The "little woman" as stay at home wife, mother, and homemaker epitomized by family sitcoms of the 1950s and 1960s was an idealized image even then. Today, in the 21st century, it’s as relevant as the buggy whip.

When pioneer women made the great migration from the Midwest to Utah, they did so at the side of men, sharing equally in the sacrifice and rewards of the journey and its goal. In the 19th century Mormon women were in the forefront fighting for women’s suffrage. Utah became the second territory to grant women the right to vote. And it was the first to elect a woman, Martha Hughes Cannon, a pioneer and doctor, as the nation’s first female senator in 1896—twenty-four years before the nineteenth amendment was passed.

Pay inequity for women hits families where it hurts most: the pocketbook. A lower income means less money for food, clothing, and shelter for the family, and turns other necessities like health care into luxuries.

The top ranking of pay inequity for working women in Utah also has corrosive long-term affects on businesses in the state. It means businesses have a harder time attracting and retaining female middle and upper management professionals. Though women make up 44 percent of the workforce, women only hold 8.4 percent of board positions in Utah’s top forty-five public companies, and twenty-five of those companies have no women directors and seventeen have just one.

Okay, that’s the bad news. The good news is that the women of Utah have the power to change things, the power to help move Utah from first to last and get an "A" for the state. At one level, it’s running for political office. Like the rest of the nation, Utah needs to have more women holding public office. But more fundamentally, it’s the power of the vote and it’s a power stronger than you think. Women in Utah both register to vote and vote at higher rates than men. exercising their right to vote, the women of Utah have the power to bring change that improve the lives of everyone, men and women, young and old, who live and work in Utah.

Donna McAleer is a congressional candidate in Utah’s 1st District, Army veteran, author, businesswoman, member of the Defense Advisory Council on Women in the Service and mother.

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Park City and Summit County make the Park Record's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.


Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User